Measuring What Matters: The Nonprofit Balanced Scorecard
Beyond financials, nonprofits must gauge mission success. The Balanced Scorecard (BSC) is a strategic tool expanding measurement beyond finance to multiple perspectives. This session covers creating and using a nonprofit-specific BSC, identifying metrics for continuous improvement vs. stability, and communicating success effectively.
Creating and Using the Nonprofit Balanced Scorecard
Identify Key Perspectives (3-5)
Choose broad areas critical to success. Common nonprofit perspectives include Mission/Impact, Stakeholder Satisfaction, Internal Processes, Financial Sustainability, and Learning & Growth.
Set Strategic Objectives
Define 1-3 high-level goals under each perspective, aligned with the strategic plan.
Develop KPIs
Choose 1-3 measurable Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for each objective. Use a mix of leading (predictive) and lagging (outcome) indicators.
Set Targets
Establish specific, achievable performance targets for each KPI, indicating desired improvement ("Go Up") or maintenance levels ("Stay Same").
Implement Data Collection
Ensure reliable systems are in place to gather KPI data (financials, HR records, surveys, databases).
Use in Governance
Regularly review the BSC at board meetings. Use dashboards (often color-coded: green/yellow/red) to monitor progress, identify issues, and foster holistic strategic discussions beyond just finances.
Cascade and Align
While the board uses high-level metrics, the BSC can inform departmental goals. Align board committee oversight with BSC perspectives.
Review and Refresh
Periodically update the BSC to ensure metrics remain relevant and drive focus on "what matters."
Adapted from Kaplan and Norton, the BSC helps nonprofits strategically monitor performance. Unlike traditional models, nonprofits often elevate Mission/Impact above financial outcomes, viewing finance as a means to an end.
A tailored BSC helps nonprofits balance mission effectiveness with financial stewardship, providing a nuanced view of organizational health.
Which Metrics Should Continuously Improve ("Go Up")?
Mission Reach & Impact
Increasing the number of people served, benefits provided, or geographic reach (e.g., meals served, clients housed).
Outcome Success Rates
Improving the quality or effectiveness of programs (e.g., % of participants achieving desired outcomes like graduation or employment).
Supporter Base
Growing the number of donors, members, or volunteers; improving donor retention.
Revenue & Resources
Increasing overall revenue (especially unrestricted funds or operating reserves) to fuel mission expansion.
Capacity & Influence
Strengthening organizational ability (e.g., partnerships formed, brand awareness, advocacy reach, volunteer hours contributed).
Efficiency
Improving productivity (e.g., reducing cost per outcome, increasing clients served per staff if quality is maintained).
Key Considerations: While aiming for continuous improvement is common, set realistic targets and use the BSC to balance quantitative growth against qualitative outcomes, ensuring growth doesn't dilute impact unintentionally.
Which Metrics Should Maintain Standards ("Stay the Same")?
Mission Fidelity & Ethics
Consistently upholding core values and ethical practices.
Quality & Safety Thresholds
Ensuring critical standards never drop below a set level (e.g., maintaining zero safety incidents, 100% regulatory compliance, high program fidelity).
Financial Stability
Keeping key financial health indicators within target ranges or above minimum floors (e.g., maintaining adequate operating reserves, balanced budgets).
Stakeholder Satisfaction
Sustaining high levels of client, staff, or volunteer satisfaction once desired levels are achieved.
Operational Consistency
Maintaining acceptable overhead ratios or consistent service delivery standards.
Not all goals involve growth; maintaining high standards or stability is equally critical. These metrics often represent non-negotiables.
These "stay the same" metrics act as control measures or performance floors, ensuring foundational elements aren't compromised while pursuing improvements elsewhere.
Communicating Success: Telling Your Impact Story
Combine Data and Stories
Pair quantitative KPIs with qualitative examples ("mission moments," client success stories) to illustrate human impact.
Visualize Key Results
Use charts, graphs, and infographics for clarity and quick comprehension of trends.
Tailor the Message
Simplify language and focus for different audiences (board details vs. donor impact). Make it relatable.
Highlight Progress & Consistency
Showcase upward trends ("Go Up") and celebrate maintained standards ("Stay Same," e.g., safety records).
Incorporate Stakeholder Voices
Use testimonials from beneficiaries, partners, or volunteers for credibility and personalization.
Connect Contribution to Impact
Clearly show how support (donations, time, policy) translates into tangible outcomes. Frame success as shared success.
Use a Narrative Arc
Structure stories around challenge, action, and result (before/after).
Be Transparent
Honestly report all results, including shortfalls. Frame challenges as learning opportunities to build trust.
Use Multiple Channels
Adapt the story for annual reports, newsletters, social media, board meetings, etc. Ensure board members echo the message.
Keep Mission Front & Center
Regularly connect the data back to the core purpose, reminding the board and stakeholders why the work matters.
In Practice: Create accessible summaries like an "Impact Report" blending key metrics, visuals, and stories. Effective storytelling combines accountability ("head") with inspiration ("heart"), fostering confidence and sustained support.
Nonprofit Board Governance Guide
This comprehensive guide breaks down nonprofit governance into eight essential sections.
Whether you're new to board service or a seasoned leader, you'll find valuable insights.
Ditch the Email Chaos. Manage Your Nonprofit Board the Smart Way.
Tired of scattered documents, endless email threads, and tracking down votes? Quorum brings everything your board needs into one secure, affordable platform.
Lost Files?
Centralized dashboard with secure AWS S3 document storage keeps everything organized.
Meeting Mayhem?
Integrated agendas, notes and decision logging with rich text editing.
Voting Hassles?
Secure online voting with anonymous options, receipts and easy tracking.
Just $20/Board/Month with unlimited members included. No per-user fees.